We often think of a hostile work environment as something that happens when a fellow co-worker or supervisor acts inappropriately. But a hostile work environment can also be created by a customer, and the company can be held responsible where it fails to quickly act. In the words of the Ninth Circuit (the federal court covering Arizona), an employer creates the hostile work environment where it “either ratifies or acquiesces in the harassment by not taking immediate and/or corrective actions when it knew or should have known of the conduct.”
Jennifer Christian worked at Umpqua Bank as a teller when a banking customer began making her feel uncomfortable. Over the course of several months, the customer persistently returned to the bank to express his romantic intentions. The customer repeatedly dropped off notes and flowers for Jennifer, declaring that she was “the most beautiful girl” and that they “were meant to be together.” The behavior escalated when he appeared at a company charity event where Jennifer was volunteering and then, on a separate day, appeared in the bank lobby staring at Jennifer for an hour.
Although Jennifer told multiple co-workers and supervisors that she felt unsafe, management failed to close the customer’s bank account and declined to issue him a no-trespassing notice that would have barred him from returning. After the company finally agreed to close the customer’s account, apparently changed course again, deciding to re-open the account. To add insult to injury, Jennifer’s supervisor asked her to re-open it.
Vincent Fried worked as a manicurist at a Las Vegas resort. One day, he was assigned to give a pedicure to a male customer in the salon. The pedicure service began normally, but it quickly escalated. The customer asked Vincent to come up to his hotel room and give him a massage, saying he had massage oil. Vincent pushed back and responded “we don’t do that kind of service,” but the customer persisted, commenting “it is wonderful to have sex with another man.”
Vincent immediately reported the customer’s harassing behavior to his manager. Instead of asking the customer to leave or assigning the patron to a different manicurist, Vincent’s manager told him to “just get it over with” and finish the manicure. In total, the customer made around five or six sexual comments to Vincent during the visit. His manager did nothing to help. By telling him to finish the pedicure even though he felt unsafe, she allowed her employee to continue to be subject to a hostile work environment.
In both instances, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals found that the employer was on the hook for sexual harassment (ie, a hostile work environment). In both cases, the managers failed to adequately address the employee’s concerns. In both cases, the customer’s behavior amounted to a potential safety concern.
If you believe you have been the victim of a hostile work environment created by a customer, client, patient, or other third party, it’s important to find an attorney so you can hold your employer accountable.
