When we think of racial harassment, we most often think of someone from one racial group targeting someone of a different race. For example, a white supervisor using offensive language toward a Latino worker. But what do the anti- discrimination laws say about same-race discrimination?
In 1977, the Supreme Court first addressed this topic in a case involving a Texas county where 79% of the population was Mexican-American but just 39% of grand jurors were Mexican-American. A prisoner challenged his conviction, arguing that the grand jury system was racist. Such a large disparity could only be explained if intentional discrimination were involved, he argued. But the local government pointed out that Mexican-Americans largely ran the judicial system and oversaw the selection of jurors. Mexican-Americans had a ‘governing majority’ and political dominance. Is it possible for a particular racial group to illegally discriminate against itself? The Supreme Court answered yes.
“It would be unwise to presume”, the Supreme Court reasoned, “that human beings of one definable group will not discriminate against other members of their group.” Justice Thurgood Marshall added his own thoughts, rejecting the notion that “all members of all minority groups have an inclination to assure fairness to other members of their group.” He said that such assumptions “fly in the face” of social science research and history.
This same principle applies to discrimination cases brought under Title VII (the law outlawing workplace discrimination) and the Fair Housing Act (the law banning housing discrimination). Below are some examples of how courts handle same-race discrimination when it happens in the workplace or in housing.
Serita Agnew began a new job at a Texas nonprofit organization. Both Serita and her boss, Donald Sneed, were Black. On Serita’s first day on the job, Sneed berated her with racist slurs. And he continued for years, calling Serita and other Black employees the n-word and other slurs. He would hurl racial epithets during staff meetings, in the hallways, and in the parking lot. This racial harassment left Serita a nervous wreck, making it impossible to do her job.
When Serita complained, she discovered that the board of directors had long known of the abusive behavior but no-one was willing to meaningful confront it. Instead, Serita was told “that’s just how he is.” Serita resigned after years of almost-daily racial harassment from Sneed.
In a rare move, the E.E.O.C. – the agency responsible for enforcing workplace discrimination laws – brought suit on behalf of Serita and other Black co-workers. The E.E.O.C. wrote in a court filing that “the fact that Sneed, as an African-American, directed these racial slurs to his Black employees does not negate the racial animus required to support a claim for racial harassment.” Shortly after this filing, the organization led by Sneed agreed to a sweeping consent decree (a form of settlement agreement).
Odis Ross, a Black man, worked for several years at a county jail in Nebraska. His supervisor was Larry Johnson, also a Black man. Johnson would occasionally call Odis the n-word and “black boy”. Similar to Serita in Texas, Odis eventually resigned.
In the lawsuit that followed, the court said: “we have no doubt that, as a matter of law, a black male could discriminate against another black male because of such individual’s race.” The court added: “that Johnson was also black does not alter” the conclusion. After all, Title VII (the federal antidiscrimination law) makes it unlawful for an employer to “discriminate against any individual…because of such individual’s race.” Nothing suggests that it applies only to discrimination between different racial groups.
The same is true under the Fair Housing Act – the federal law that applies to discrimination between landlords and tenants. Take, for example, the case of Clifton Hylton. He was a Black landlord, and his white tenants wanted to sublease their apartment for a few months. Hylton initially agreed to allow his tenants to sublease. But then he learned that the subletters were Black. Then, he refused. His reasoning? He didn’t want “too many blacks” at the property. He instructed his white tenants to find “good white people that could afford” to sublet the property.
The case presents textbook housing discrimination, and the fact that the landlord was Black doesn’t change that. The law is clear: members of the same protected class can discriminate against members of the same protected class. If you have been discriminated against because of your race, even if it’s coming from someone who is the same race as you, that’s still discrimination.
