August 10, 2026
The E.E.O.C. – the federal agency responsible for enforcing antidiscrimination laws – weighed in on a lawsuit brought by the Arizona Civil Rights Law Center. In an Amicus brief, the EEOC urged the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to rule in favor of one of our clients who had been fired by Southwest Airlines.
Muzaffer Cecen was born and raised in Turkey, lived for many years in Arizona, and worked for Southwest Airlines for 13 years. Until his firing, Muzaffer had accumulated a perfect attendance record and positive job reviews. In 2023, he was in the breakroom when a co-worker called him a “dirty Indian” and “terrorist.” The next day, Muzaffer complained to his supervisor. He was fired several weeks later.
The Arizona Civil Rights Law Center sued, arguing that Muzaffer was unlawfully retaliated against for reporting racial harassment. Southwest Airlines agreed that Muzaffer was called these offensive terms yet argued that the breakroom incident wasn’t race-based harassment in the first instance. According to Southwest, being called a “terrorist” and “dirty Indian” was offensive but not offensive enough. According to Southwest Airlines’ logic, the verbal abuse must be more extreme and the humiliation more painful. The District Court agreed, concluding that Muzaffer complained about something that no reasonable person would believe to be racial harassment.
On appeal, the Arizona Civil Rights Law Center argued that these racial slurs created a hostile work environment. And even if they didn’t, Muzaffer was still justified in complaining to his supervisor. After all, Muzaffer sincerely believed that he had suffered a racially hostile work environment. And others in his situation would reasonably think so too.
The E.E.O.C. took no position on whether a hostile work environment takes shape when a co-worker calls another co-worker a “dirty Indian” or “terrorist”. Instead, the E.E.O.C. argued that Muzaffer opposed something that he reasonably believed to be unlawful, even if he were later proven to be wrong. By virtue of complaining about something he reasonably believed to be unlawful, the E.E.O.C. argued, Muzaffer should have been protected from retaliation.
The E.E.O.C. rarely contributes amicus briefs. In 2026, the E.E.O.C. is expected to file just 30 amicus briefs nationwide. Between 1995 and 2024, the E.E.O.C. filed an average of just 18 per year. Meanwhile, American workers file about 13,000 discrimination lawsuits each year. The E.E.O.C. submits amicus briefs only where the case raises novel or important legal issues. In this case, the E.E.O.C. told the court that it believed Muzaffer’s case raised “important questions regarding what a plaintiff must show to establish protected opposition activity under Title VII’s anti-retaliation provision.” The E.E.O.C. last filed an amicus brief in the Ninth Circuit in October 2024.
The case is cited as Muzaffer Cecen v. Southwest Airlines, Inc.
