July 23, 2026
The Arizona Civil Rights Law Center has filed a federal lawsuit against a local law enforcement officer who tased a motorist and then triggered criminal charges against him in retaliation for his filing a civil rights claim.
William Simpson was driving 10 mph over the speed limit along Interstate 10 when he was stopped by Pinal County Sheriff’s Deputy Brando Reibschied in 2024. During the traffic stop, William was tased on the side of the highway while he was complying with the cops’ orders and told he would be charged with reckless driving. The months passed by with no court summons or traffic citations. William hired an attorney and filed a legal claim alleging excessive force.
After months of silence, William was summoned to court just 14 days after he filed his excessive force claim. The government brought five criminal charges against him, seeking to give him a felony record. The Arizona Civil Rights Law Center defended William in his criminal charges and argued that the peculiar timing suggested retaliation. As it turned out, this was only the beginning of the ordeal.
For 14 months, the Arizona Civil Rights Law Center tried – and failed – to obtain basic documents in order to prove the retaliatory motive. The Sheriff’s Department withheld critical video footage and internal correspondence. The criminal judge dismissed the charges on July 8, observing that “there’s obviously some hiding the ball going on”, that the government’s failure to disclose documents “would appear to be a violation of Mr. Simpson’s rights”, and that he was “disappointed” that the county attorney’s office didn’t “exercise their strong discretion and the strong power” to “make the sheriff’s office comply.”
Investigative reporting by the Phoenix New Times revealed that William’s experience may have been part of a pattern in Pinal County: The sheriff’s office appears to bring criminal charges against people who intend to sue. Earlier in the year, the Phoenix New Times reported on the case of Thomas Garro, a 79-year-old deaf Lyft driver who was carrying a passenger when a Pinal County deputy stopped the vehicle and roughed him up. The passenger was so concerned for Mr. Garro’s safety that she called 911 from the back seat because she feared the deputies were going to kill him. Similar to William, Mr. Garro was not initially charged with any crime. It wasn’t until his story was reported in the news and Mr. Garro’s attorney indicated a plan to file a legal claim that he was slapped with felony charges.
William Simpson’s ordeal led him to move out-of-state. The lawsuit seeks monetary compensation for both the tasing itself and the retaliatory criminal charges that cast a shadow over his life for almost a year and a half.
